Traditional Dojo Adding Other Arts As Supplements

MatsuShinshii · Black Belt

I see nothing wrong with having supplements as long as it does not take away from your main purpose and main art. If this is extra to your art and does not take away time allotted from your main art, then I see no issue.

wildbourgman · Orange Belt

This reply may not have anything to do with your post but the term "watering down" hits home with me.

I originally coming from a Japanese style that was "watered down" from Okinawan traditional martial arts. I had commented during a discussion with elder instructors from the Japanese art that were complaining about BJJ and other MMA schools taking students from them. I said maybe they could look at some of the Okinawan arts for grappling techniques to supplement what they teach. Then one of the complainers said "what should we do, water down our system?"

I was respectful and said nothing, because all I instantly knew to say was that he was the one complaining and looking for answers and if he knew the history of his art, he would also know when and how it was watered down which is causing his problems today. So rather than not having a better reply I allowed others to answer him in a more proper way than I was prepared for.

As to your question, Shorin Ryu being your foundation has many aspects to pick from that should keep you busy, but you can successfully supplement it with other systems as needed. That supplementation won't adversely affect the structure that you are building on if your foundation is solid!
_________________
WildBourgMan

	KarateForums.com Forum Index -> Karate	All times are GMT - 6 Hours Goto page Previous 1, 2
Page 2 of 2