Very New; Trying to avoid "McDojos"

Brooknite · White Belt

My whole life I wanted to study and train in a martial art but never got around to it or was unable to, due to personal reasons. It wasn't until I came very close to getting my butt beat at a bar last week where I realized I need to learn how to defend myself, especially if it saves my life one day. So, I started looking around via Google for any martial arts school(minus kickboxing and boxing), that would conform with my work schedule and is something that will be effective in a street fight.

The first place I checked out is a http://www.brooklynbjj.com/ I was interested, but then realized BJJ is useless if I am fighting 1 guy on the ground and his 3 friends are kicking me in my face while I'm down there.

The second place that conforms to my work schedule is a Wing Chun school (Moy Yat lineage) http://www.nycvingtsun.com/Welcome.html

As for the third, well I went to a shotokan karate school yesterday http://www.ruskinkarate.com/, just to see a class and check it out. The class was about a hour long and I liked the teacher, but I have some reservations about it.

I was watching a class with all brown belts and I was not really impressed. One guy, it seemed, had no idea what he was doing, kicking super slow, not listening, it made me wonder just how he got that brown belt and why.

After class, the teacher wanted to sign me up right away. He told me I can do month to month or get a 6 month/1 year plan. If I paid once a month its $140 to go 2 times a week and $160 to go 3 times a week. That really seems a bit high. I told him I wanted to check out other schools before I made my decision and he seemed so insulted. He asked which schools and after I told him the schools he repeated, "You'll be back" like 10 times. Then he said how most teachers don't know how to teach and how he was the best teacher. This was a BIG turnoff to me. I don't like pushy salesman, they are my antithesis. The only real upside to this place was I got there in 10 minutes from my house which is nice.

Later in the week, I am going to check out a MMA/Martial arts gym http://www.fightfactoryny.com/. They are rather expensive but with the price you pay you get full access to a gym with free weights and smith machines along with 3 classes (1.5 hours a class) of your choice a week; they offer, MMA Fighting, Muay Thai, Boxing, Karate, Wrestling. For them it's $200 a month if I sign up for a year.

My biggest fear is that I get injured like 4 months into the training and then I'm out a big chunk of change, so I really want something that is month to month. This is not making my life any easier because there are so many, "McDojos" out there and I dont want to invest my money in something that is taught by a hack and/or is bogus.

FWIW, I will be checking out a Kyokukshin karate place http://brooklynkyokushinkarate.com/ later this week. It's about a 15 minute highway drive from my house, but their website shows that its $99 a month with no contract. I'm not sure how Kyokukshin karate differes from Shotokan karate? Anyway, I'm going crazy here trying to figure out what to do. In Brooklyn alone there are 5.5 million people, you would think their would be more/better schools to choose from.

My Stats:

•25 Year old
•5'10
•168 lbs
•14%-15% body fat
•Never worked out more than 6 months in my whole life

Any tips or feedback would be great. Thanks!

MasterPain · Black Belt

BJJ is never useless. How are you supposed to stay off the ground if you don't know any grappling? They have takedowns and takedown defense as well as groundwork. Royce Gracie didn't need 3 friends to beat up Ron Van Cleef on the ground, he did it very well on his own. Personally, I find the idea of fighting multiple attackers unarmed ridiculous. Even monkeys use sticks to get food.

MMA would be great if you can afford it. Kyokushin tends to focus on full contact competitive fighting, be prepared for a workout. Check around for FMA as well. There are a lot of backyard and basement FMA groups that don't charge much of anything.
_________________
My fists bleed death. -Akuma

Dobbersky · Black Belt

I'd say Kyokushin, would be your best option, all grapplers tell you most fights end up on the floor, no they don't. A maximum of 40% do, and that's because the grapplers bring it to the floor.

George St Pierre is a Kyokushin blackbelt and he beats many grapplers WITHOUT taking it to the ground. Bruce Lee never took any of his fights to the ground and most treat him like a demi-god.

I'd recommend Ashihara or Enshin karate IF there's a school near you as it's a modern style and it teaches you stand-up and ground defense.

Try all the schools if they offer a free class or 2 and see what suits YOU the best.
_________________
"Challenge is a Dragon with a Gift in its mouth....Tame the Dragon and the Gift is Yours....." Noela Evans (author)

JusticeZero · Black Belt

kensei · Orange Belt

First off Kyokushin is close to Shotokan, but a more sporty and aggressive contact system. More people get hurt in that style but not badly hurt, kind of beat up and off with sore ribs for a few weeks.

Next some misconceptions about grappling. First off only about 40% of fights go to the ground with both people on the ground, normally its one guy over the other and pounding on the beat down guy. Jitsu will help if you get into this situation to help you get up, but if there are more than 2 guys you are fighting…most styles wont help you really. A bat will however!

For the money, its crazy to charge more than $60 a month for two classes a week, and probably not worth it. Rank means very little in relation to skills these days. Not that this makes the club a McDojo, but it might be. The instructor in question belongs to a legit organization and probably teaches mostly family style Karate. You can benefit from the Shotokan guy and he is legit, but to what extent you will benefit is up to you.

My suggestion is you sit down and write out your goals. Show it to each instructor and ask for feed back as to how long, if that is a focus of the club, what kind of benefits they offer you did not think of and do your research. Don’t jump in to fast and make sure you are going in with the understanding that each club is different and may not offer what you are looking for or part of what you are looking for.
_________________
Even monkeys fall from trees

sensei8 · KF Sensei

First of all...Welcome to KF!!

You've received some solid advice thus far. Imho, avoid, at any cost, contracts because they are very binding, and in that, they're almost impossible to get out of if something should happen, you'll still have to pay each and every month.

_________________
**Proof is on the floor!!!

Bryan Sensei · White Belt

In my opinion any school that makes you sign a yearly or "so called lifetime member "contracks is particularly foolish .Especially when it comes to kids,because kids lose interests very fast and once you or your kids lose interests your still on the hook for the contract.And as others have stated anymore than about $60 to $75 per month for martial arts is also plain foolishness.Teachers who change large amounts of money for lessons are more interested in money than promoting the art or love for the art.
_________________
There's no such word as can't.

Rateh · Red Belt

Realize that different areas charge different amounts. I know of no school in my area that charges under $99 a month. And no school that does not do a contract. Yes, there are places in the world, even places in the U.S. that charge very low per month. But to say "don't go to a school that charges more than X amount" greatly limits the schools available. Like I said, in my area, NO commercial schools charge lower than $99 a month, and none of them do so without a contract. If you want to train for less, and no contract, you would have to train at a fitness center. This means very limited class times, and generally all ranks and sometimes even all ages lumped together.

So my advice, do not use price as a major determining factor, unless the place is more expensive than you can afford.
_________________
Your present circumstances don't determine where you can go; they merely determine where you start. - Nido Qubein

Wastelander · KF Sensei

As Rateh stated, it's all well and good to say that people shouldn't sign contracts or pay more than $60 a month, but in some areas that just isn't a possibility. Where I am from, for example, martial arts schools are considered a "sports training facility" and are required, by law, to have contracts. Where I currently live, you aren't going to find martial arts training for less than $90 a month, with the exception of some judo or programs run out of the YMCA.

What you really need to do is find a school with an instructor that you like that teaches good material in a format that works well for you. You shouldn't worry so much about the style you practice as its effectiveness (do the techniques work under pressure?), it's comprehensiveness (covers striking range, clinching range, and grappling) and how well it is being taught (for you, personally).
_________________
Kishimoto-Di | 2014-Present | Sensei: Ulf Karlsson
Shorin-Ryu/Shinkoten Karate | 2010-Present: Yondan, Renshi | Sensei: Richard Poage (RIP), Jeff Allred (RIP)
Shuri-Ryu | 2006-2010: Sankyu | Sensei: Joey Johnston, Joe Walker (RIP)
Judo | 2007-2010: Gokyu | Sensei: Joe Walker (RIP), Ramon Rivera (RIP), Adrian Rivera
Illinois Practical Karate | International Neoclassical Karate Kobudo Society

Aodhan · Black Belt

	KarateForums.com Forum Index -> Choosing a Martial Art, Comparing Styles, and Cross-Training	All times are GMT - 6 Hours Goto page 1, 2, 3 Next
Page 1 of 3