Anyone recognise any of these katas?

LastKing · Yellow Belt

As you may or may not remember, I've been trying to track down these kata for a long time now, but can't seem to find them anywhere. They are known in the club as:

Kenkasho
https://facebook.com/kernowkarateexeter/videos/1466254470119881/

Kenkasho here is at about 4.36. Kintano at 5.08, and Pinan Sandan at 6.10:
https://youtu.be/maY58JXLxZM

I've seen plenty of youtube videos on Pinan sandan, but it bears no resemblance to these.

Any comments gratefully received.

JR 137 · Black Belt

They’re not any traditional kata that I’ve ever seen. They appear to be kata most likely developed by someone within that specific organization/school. That’s most likely why you’re not finding anything about them beyond videos made/posted by that school.

There’s nothing wrong with that if you know why they teach them and you’re ok with their reasons. If you’re looking for traditional kata, I’m quite sure this isn’t what you’re looking for.

I’ve got no problem with kata developed by someone recently. Our founder has made a few of his own. They’re in line with everything else we do and don’t seem like something thrown together just to look cool. They’re not my favorite kata and I could just as easily do without them and/or replace them with traditional kata, but I enjoy one or two of them that I know. We do far more traditional kata (as in number of kata) than just the ones developed by our founder. The traditional ones we do are popular ones found elsewhere and are very close to Kyokushin’s version of them.

LastKing · Yellow Belt

Thanks for that. Am I right in thinking that if anyone wanted to compete in outside kata competition, it would have to be with a recognized kata?

Wado Heretic · Green Belt

Kenkasho appears to have elements taken from Kuskanku, Unsu, and Wanshu. Kintano, on the other hand, appears to take primarily from Kushanku with elements from Fyukyugata/Gekisai or Kururunfa.

Both display the issues of creativity I expect from newly developed kata. Non-combative movements such as the fall back onto the side, the roll across the stomach, and the kneeling punches in Kenkasho. Too many movements being done on the spot in a posture not suitable for the techniques being done, standing and moving to face opposing sides, and moving from one posture into a mirror of the same posture in Kintano.

The names are also functionally nonsense, even to an absolute amateur in Japanese such as myself. Kenka, broadly speaking, can mean fighting or brawling, and Sho in the context of martial arts practice is usually used as Beginning. Thus, Kenka Sho could be transliterated as Fighting Beginning or the Beginning of the Fighting, but Kenkasho as a compound phrase is nonsensical. Kintano appears to me like someone heard the myth of Kintaro and changed the Ro to No. Which changes the meaning from Gold, Fat Son, to Gold, Fat My, presuming we use No as a possessive. Could also be Gold, Fat Of if we used the older meaning.

All the evidence points to these Forms being created specifically for this particular branch of the Karate tree. Would I consider them worthy of study from what I watched? In all honesty, no: I would advise one goes study the original kata from which these forms borrow heavily. I would replace Kenkasho with Unsu, and if you have time to practice Kintano you have the time practice Kushanku. Mostly because more people practice said kata, and you will have more luck finding resources to help you improve, and get a deeper understanding of the kata. Also, I fear from what I have seen that both of those forms encourage unsound ways of moving in actual physical combat.

Generally, when it comes to unusual versions of the Pinan I usually suspect reverse engineering from the Cat Kata of Nick Cerio's Kempo Karate, or the Pinion Forms of Shaolin Kempo Karate or Kajukenbo. I must say I have never seen that form, never mind seen something like that called Pinan Sandan.

None of this is a remark against the system of Kernow Karate in general, just these particular kata. Regarding the system as a whole, it is very much the general Middle of the Road Karate I see in most of the United Kingdom. The people in the video seem to deeply enjoy their practice, and that is what matters at the end of the day.

Edit: What sort of Form competition you enter will depend on the kata you can submit. The WKF and associated groups have moved away from the Shi-tei Kata, which were mandatory qualifying kata every competitor had to perform. They were controversial for being from Shotokan, Wado-Ryu, Goju-Ryu, and Shi-te-Ryu alone, meaning if you did not practice one of these styles you would have to learn a shi-tei kata from one of these systems to simply compete. They may be gone, however, the WKF does still have a list of recognised kata which must still be adhered to.

You could enter such Forms in an Open-Style competition, just make sure to enter the right sort. Free-Style often includes a lot of "tricking" even if the forms are based on traditional ones. Extreme Martial Arts, or XMA, incorporates acrobatics and gymnastics and focuses very much on showmanship.

I should also explain what I mean by the middle of the road. What I mean is three K karate that does Bunkai and Bukiwaza. It does not seem to be a form of Jissen Karate as propagated by Abernathy and that ilk. A form of Koshiki Karate as from Okinawa. A form of Kenka Karate as Kyokushin and its descendants are. Nor Shiai Karate which emphasises competition as is promoted by the WKF.
_________________
R. Keith Williams

LastKing · Yellow Belt

Thanks for that. I appreciate the input and the advice on kata. And thanks for the input on the club. It's one I've taken over and we have a girl who has real potential, but not sure how she would go about competition if the kata are not recognised.

Age-Uke · Yellow Belt

sensei8 · KF Sensei

I watched both video links provided in the OP, each several times, and to me, quite honestly, I still have not even a minimum of an idea what any of it is!!

_________________
**Proof is on the floor!!!

LastKing · Yellow Belt

Thanks for that.

wagnerk · Purple Belt

Looking at the video, then at their website, it appears like they are very loosely based on forms from Shorinryu Karate - how which form, I'm not really sure. Since they are a a modern freestyle Karate style, don't expect their forms to be readily recognized outside their own style...
_________________
Tang Soo Do: 3rd Dan '18
Karate: 2nd Dan '04

Wastelander · KF Sensei

As others have mentioned, those kata look made up. As a Shorin-Ryu practitioner, I can say that the kata are far removed from anything I've learned, and the mechanics are lacking. Actually, it kind of reminds me of the mechanics I tend to see from competition TKD forms, more than Shorin-Ryu.
_________________
Kishimoto-Di | 2014-Present | Sensei: Ulf Karlsson
Shorin-Ryu/Shinkoten Karate | 2010-Present: Yondan, Renshi | Sensei: Richard Poage (RIP), Jeff Allred (RIP)
Shuri-Ryu | 2006-2010: Sankyu | Sensei: Joey Johnston, Joe Walker (RIP)
Judo | 2007-2010: Gokyu | Sensei: Joe Walker (RIP), Ramon Rivera (RIP), Adrian Rivera
Illinois Practical Karate | International Neoclassical Karate Kobudo Society

	KarateForums.com Forum Index -> Karate	All times are GMT - 6 Hours
Page 1 of 1