Is "how much force to use" the wrong question?

MasterPain · Black Belt

For that matter, what is a cop? He is a citizen who has taken it upon himself, as a job, to serve and protect the safety of his fellow citizens. This is a respectable job, but should any other person with the means to protect his neighbors refuse to do so because it is not their job? If it is in my power to restrain a dangerous individual until the authorities show up, isn't it my duty as a citizen to do so?
_________________
My fists bleed death. -Akuma

Liver Punch · Green Belt

I'm not hurling myself toward anything. I'm standing at a safe distance with a weapon pointed toward a threat shouting instructions to them to stay in a non-threatening position. I'm not attacking them - I've already defended myself, I'm keeping them neutralized.

Of course, I could take the word of someone who's obviously under the influence of alcohol and in a state where they are prepared to hurt or kill another human being. Why wouldn't I assume that they're a threat to themselves or others? I'm not taking anything this person says as the truth.

Why did I defend myself to start with? Shouldn't the people with badges take care of that? Why do I have a 1911 on my person? It's not a hunting gun..its purpose is defense. That's the job of the police. In fact, I'm doing the police's job if I take any sort of action in this situation. I should probably throw away my first aid kit and fire extinguisher because that's EMS and the Fire Fighter's job.

As a citizen with a concealed carry permit, my state has deemed it legal for me to carry and use a firearm in the defense of myself and others. So, once I've created space, and given myself enough time to draw my weapon, the number of things that can happen decrease substantially.

The payoff is that I don't run inside and loose control of a situation that had seconds earlier been much less dangerous. If you want to run inside and watch an armed and dangerous person roam your neighborhood, be my guest. My obligation is a moral one - I don't want my neighbors and random passer-by's to be stabbed.

Just because we CAN stand by and let bad things happen doesn't make a good idea.
_________________
"A gun is a tool. Like a butcher knife or a harpoon, or uhh... an alligator."
― Homer, The Simpsons

Groinstrike · Pre-Black Belt

Snarkyness aside, i agree with Liverpunch. That being said i do not condone every joe blow who owns a gun to be riding around like Charles Bronson being a vigilante.

Hurling yourself needlessly into a dangerous situation is dumb, i think we can all agree on that, but it you have the means and the ability to control a situation and keep it from escelating to something worse, whether that means using a firearm or just using words i agree that we as martial artists and fellow human beings have a moral obligation to do so.

Evil is created with good men are indifferent.

bushido_man96 · KF Sensei

bushido_man96 · KF Sensei

RazeMMA · White Belt

dragonwarrior_keltyr · Orange Belt

For me, I'm under five feet and 110 pounds. I'm small and "vulnerable." So for me, I think doing anything I need to get away is what I'd do. I'm an easy target, and I can be overpowered. It's an unfortunate fact of being small - someone can out-muscle me. Overall, I think that size plays a factor. If a 300lb guy attacks me, I would be more likely to use as much force as possible because of the size difference. Whereas, someone who is more my height, I wouldn't see the need to use as much force because they aren't as physically imposing. Perhaps, that isn't a good attitude, but that's just how I react.
_________________
External training without the training of the mind is nothing

JusticeZero · Black Belt

No, it sounds good to me..
The attitude that worries me is when these questions come up and people immediately plan to go on the attack, and start thinking only of how much damage they can do instead of how to, you know, protect and defend themself.
_________________
"Anything worth doing is worth doing badly." - Baleia

madtanker · Orange Belt

[quote="tallgeese"]Good question. And I think I've been part of multiple of tests where similar questions were asked. Don't you hate the sound of your own voice?

Anyway, I can see where you're coming from and it's an area that need complete discussion within any school that even looks in the direction of combative application of the arts for self defense.

I'm big these days on teaching the use of of force needed. Period. No as little or as much as you can, just what's needed. It's the safest in terms of teaching people to not UNDER respond (a major problem) and not getting people so worked up that they move from self defense to aggravated battery (which is what I think I was geared towards during some of my days of training- thanks USBBA).

This teaches a fluid mindset in regard to use of force. This should go hand in hand with fluid mindset as far as tactical application of tools. Your response has to go up and down the scale as your bad guy attacks and desists. So, if he throws a punch and you evade and counter with a strike, your good. Then you launch a double leg to control him. So far so good. If he puts his hands in submission, you need to not strike him from your new, super- cool dominate position. If however, he retrieves a knife from his waistband, you'd best be ready to drive your tactics up to meet the force. So maybe you check the draw and up your bludgeoning and clubbery to his head (or check his draw and present your firearm to escalate- whatever you've got handy).

If at this point (assuming you haven't deployed a .45 round in a contact shot) let's say he has a bit of your bullying and decides to stop trying to get his knife arm free. He drops the knife and tosses it aside cries uncontrollably. Now you need to adjust down, stop beating him about the head and neck (or re-engage the safety on your pistol) and start making use of your joint position training to control him in a fetal position until the cops get there. Maybe provide some career counseling on why attacking random people on the street is a bad idea (I'm not above amusing yourself a little here on a cerebral level).

This sliding application really get to the heart of the issue and trains people not to under or over respond without getting caught up in some artificial "use of force continuum" (a system used in law enforcement that we created ourselves to be confusing and unnecessary. State and federal law says noting about the concept nor has any use of force rulings in case law ever).[/quote]

OUTSTANDING... beating about the face and neck...

The rule I have been taught in LEO training was that, you use (assuming non stopping force) 1 level above the force used against you, or to quote Sean Connery, 'if he sends one of yours to the hospital, you send one of his to the ($&%&@) morgue... that's the Chicago way'...
Not really... You DO have to end the fight as soon as an attacker disengages. You can hold for law enforcement (assuming you are trying to effect a citizen's arrest, or something similar), you can defend, block, or end the fight with a punch, but you can NEVER have been the aggressor in a deadly force situation. You have to remember, a jury of 12 people will have to review whether they (usually with no training of their own) would have roundhoused this guy to the head, or whether the jury (of old cat-ladies and 'gentlemen') would have dropped their medication and social security checks and run...
Remember, balance is key, if you are on the defensive, then defend, but never attack.
And I can say this from personal experience, if you EVER go into court and state, under oath that you attacked for any reason, YOU WILL LOSE...
The state of mind is defense... (I was in a situation where I was doing security enforcement... a man pulled a pole on me, and I a gun on him... I stated incorrectly, that the man took a defensive pose instead of saying what I wanted to say, OFFENSIVE, and that word alone got this man off of 3-5 for assault with a deadly weapon). It is in the testimony as well as the mindset!! You are NEVER an attacker in a self-defesnse situation!!
_________________
It is what you learn when you think you know everything that matters most! (unknown)
" I never saw a wild thing sorry for itself. A small bird will drop frozen dead from a bough without ever having felt sorry for itself". (DH Lawrence)
"The only stupid question is the one that was never asked!!" (Me!!!)

	KarateForums.com Forum Index -> General Martial Arts Discussion	All times are GMT - 6 Hours Goto page Previous 1, 2, 3
Page 3 of 3