Martial Arts America

Quiet Dragon · Yellow Belt

Im glad to see my first glance is the same as what you guys(or gals

) see.

Looks like "Karate for Kids" to me. As Shorinryu Sensei sadi, " looks like a belt factory".

As I said, I visited last weekend and noticed that a lot of the kids and one of the black belt instructors ( who was no older than early 20's) had all kinds of stripes on their belts. Not just a few, but some kids had like 8 stripes on their belts. Either white or yellow.

I wanted to get others opinion because for those of us who live and breathe martial arts, no matter what style, these kinds of "kid karate" "belt factory's" do the art a true injustice. As it was mentioned, you really dont expect much out of a 30 minute class do you? Except for maybe to attempt to hold a childs attention for close to that long.

Looks like a daycare with American karate mixed in......I say American karate....not martial arts.
_________________
Red belt - Hon-Shin-Do

Shorinryu Sensei · Black Belt

Not to get off the subject, but it appears we've pretty well reolved the initial question of the thread anyway at this point.

A few years ago, I moved to Houston, Tx for a short while (6 months) to do some "soul searching"...long story. Anyway, while there I would do searches on the internet, the yellow pages and just cruising down the streets in the evenings looking for different systems of martial arts that I had never seen before (I live in Montana ya know...lol).

I have never seen so many Master-this, or Master-that's in my LIFE! I'd say 90% of them placed an emphasis on flash over effectiveness, from what I saw. Flashy techniques, flashy uniforms, flashy dojo's...YUCK! I would always introduce myself to the sensei if possible and explain that I had recently moved to Houston as was looking for a place to train. I was amazed at the hard-sell sales pitch that soon followed. It made me feel like I was in a used car lot!

I saw in many of these dojo's, kids as young as 8 wearing black belts, and adults that, IMHO, didn't have the skills to be wearing a blue belt, let alone one...or more black belts. I understand that standards vary from system to system, or dojo to dojo..but some of these people were TERRIBLE!

Amyway, it was an ainteresting 6 months down there. I found some really good schools, and many more that I wouldn't bother to visit again. I've never understood how some sensei can cheapen the art, just to make money? Values are screwed up somewhere....IMHO

gheinisch · KF VIP

So true Shorinryu Sensei. I'm all for free enterprise but to take someone's money and possibly give them a false sense of security that could get them or someone else hurt is not right. As our Hanshi has said "do you want a colored belt or do you want to learn Martial Arts" if it's the later be ready for a long haul. If you just want a belt he says he can get us whatever color we want for 5 dollars in about 3 days. I choose to learn the art. Hanshi will promote no one until he feels they are ready to go on to the next challenge.

_________________
"If your hand goes forth withhold your temper"
"If your temper goes forth withold your hand"
-Gichin Funakoshi

Pride&Poise · Orange Belt

I don't really know anything about this particular school/style, but if I could just play devil's advocate for a minute...

I do think 30 minute classes could be appropriate for kids 4-6. At our school they are 45. They tried 60 minutes, but I understand they found it works better at the shorter length for kids of that age. 30 doesn't seem too short. But yes, it does seem to short for older kids and adults.

MantisWarrior · Orange Belt

i don't know America has watered down a lot of styles don't get me wrong i love my country with all my heart but its a fact.
so any style that says America in it i would be worried about.
thats jest my oppinion.
_________________
Fighting out of hate brings only disgrace.

lonewolf0323 · White Belt

There is one down the road from where I live and I wasn't impressed by it. I am in boxing and I am looking to get into a form of ma. When I went there all I saw were little kids and I talked to one of the instructors there well when I said i had done boxing he acted like I was some thug looking to get into ma to hurt people. Telling me that they try to find people that want to learn to protect themselves and not looking train people who just want to learn to fight. I guess he got mad cause he was trying to do a sales pitch of TKD on me and I told him I didn't like TKD. I don't know what the other ones teach but the one down here has TKD,Aikido,Ninjitsu, and kickboxing.

	KarateForums.com Forum Index -> General Martial Arts Discussion	All times are GMT - 6 Hours Goto page Previous 1, 2
Page 2 of 2